Archive for Thursday, April 26, 2001

Feathery fossil rekindles bird-dinosaur debate

April 26, 2001


A duck-sized dinosaur fossil unearthed in China last year sports a downy coat from head to tail, bolstering evidence that feathers arose first for insulation and not flight, scientists report.

The fossil, which likely will stoke the debate over the origin of birds, is the most complete of several found with feather-like features in China in recent years. It is dated between 126 million and 147 million years old.

Lying in a slab of petrified mud, the skeleton is fringed with feathery impressions that researchers said were left by tufts of down and primitive feathers. One scientist said the downy coat suggests that it and other two-legged carnivores called advanced theropods were warm-blooded.

"There's strong evidence that these body coverings were originally insulation for warm-blooded dinosaurs and were only later co-opted for flight," said Mark Norell, chairman of the division of paleontology at the American Museum of Natural History in New York.

The fossil, which was discovered last year and went on display Wednesday at the New York museum, is described in today's issue of the journal Nature.

Norell said the dinosaur was a dromaeosaur, a small, swift relative of the vicious Velociraptors portrayed in the film "Jurassic Park". Scientists have not determined if it represents a new species.

Richard Prum, curator of birds at Kansas University's Natural History Museum, predicted the fossil will buoy the theory that birds evolved from dinosaurs. "It is now impossible for any credible person to claim that birds are not theropod dinosaurs," he said. "It's the final straw. We've all lived long enough for the dino-deniers to have to face the evidence. This comes as close to proof as we find in science."

A scientist who examined it last year in Beijing said he saw no evidence of feathers.

"To me it's the best specimen yet showing that these structures are not feathers," said Storrs Olson, curator of birds at the National Museum of Natural History at the Smithsonian Institution. "There's nothing there that has a structure like a feather."

Olson said the feather-like covering could be many things, including impressions of decaying skin or feathery mineral crystals common to many fossils. He also questioned Norell's contention that the fossil supports the case that theropods pioneered feathers before ancient birds. Olson notes that finds of feathered theropods all appear younger than the earliest known bird, Archaeopteryx, which had highly advanced feathers.

Commenting has been disabled for this item.